Our Services

Discover What Makes Mary Arnold Toys New York’s Favorite Neighborhood Toy Store

At Mary Arnold Toys, we believe toys are more than just playthings—they’re tools for learning, bonding, and inspiring joy. As the oldest continuously operating toy store in New York City, we’re proud to offer a range of thoughtful services that reflect our commitment to quality, care, and community.

  • Gift

    FREE GIFT WRAP

    We offer free gift wrapping with every purchase - beautifully presented and ready to delight.

    Complimentary Gift Wrapping 
  • Boat

    EASY DELIVERY OPTIONS

    Can't make it to the store? We offer free local delivery in the neighborhood. (see details)

    Local Delivery & Shipping 
  • shooting star

    GIFT RECOMMENDATIONS

    Not sure what to get? We provide personalized recommendations for every age, interest, and occasion.

    Free Personal Shopping 
  • LOCAL EVENTS

    We host special in-store events: author readings, toy demo's, and seasonal celebrations. Join our mailing list below

    In-Store Events 

Questions?

Give us a call at (212) 744-8510, email us at info@maryarnoldtoys.com, or visit us at 1178
Lexington Avenue. We’re here to help!