About Mary Arnold Toys

90 Years of Play, Imagination & Joy

Welcome to Mary Arnold Toys, New York City’s oldest continuously operating toy store! Since 1931, we’ve been a beloved destination for children and families on the Upper East Side, offering a carefully curated selection of toys, games, and books that inspire creativity, learning, and endless fun.

For nearly a century, we’ve built a reputation for exceptional service, high-quality products, and a personal touch that keeps generations of customers coming back. Whether you’re searching for the perfect baby gift, a classic childhood favorite, or something truly unique, our experienced team is here to help.

A Neighborhood Treasure – In-Store & Online

Our web store showcases a selection of our most-loved products, but there’s even more to discover when you visit us in person! Need help finding something special? Give us a call at 212.477.8510—we’re always happy to assist.

We also offer free delivery to select areas of the Upper East Side:
📍 East 65th - 86th St, from 5th Ave to FDR
🚚 See Our Local Delivery Page for Additional Delivery Options

Come Play With Us!

We invite you to step inside our store and experience the magic of Mary Arnold Toys. Whether you're a longtime customer or discovering us for the first time, we can’t wait to help you find something extraordinary!

📍 Visit Us: 1178 Lexington Ave, New York, NY
📞 Call Us: 212.477.8510